More endings: This example with volta+repeat seems to me to be totally insane.
Because entering Volta 2 with a repeat start will make the repeat number be 1. This
means measure 3 should not be played the first time.
However, I have the feeling that musicians might think otherwise. And both Finale
and Musescore plays measure 3 two times. Musescore does not save the MusicXML-file
right, but puts the <repeat ...> before the <ending ...>. While the DTD says:
<!ELEMENT barline (bar-style?, %editorial;, wavy-line?,
segno?, coda?, (fermata, fermata?)?, ending?, repeat?)>
This means that <ending ...> should before <repeat ...>. But Finale does it right.
Is the volta+repeat example insane? Or am I wrong? (Should I play measure 3, when entering volta 2)
- EndingAndRepeat.jpg (12.38 KB) Viewed 907 times